Private PPO vs. Health Sharing Plans
Health sharing ministries pool members' contributions to pay each other's medical bills. The monthly cost is often low. The thing to understand clearly is that a sharing plan is not insurance, and nothing in it is a legal obligation to pay your claim.
- Pre-existing conditions covered
- Enroll any day of the year
- A licensed advisor, no pressure
- No cost to talk it through
Step 1 of 5
Let's find your coverage
Start with your state.
Plans from nationally recognized carriers
Carriers include UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Humana, Anthem, Allstate Health, Oscar.
What a private PPO can do that most plans can't.
Pre-existing conditions covered
An advisor tells you straight which plans will take your health history.
Enroll any day of the year
No six-week window. Coverage can start when you need it to.
Broad nationwide PPO networks
Keep your own doctor in most cases and stay covered across state lines.
Never sold to third parties
Your details stay with us and are never resold.
Health Sharing Ministry
What it does well
- Low monthly contributions
- Community model that suits some members' values
- No underwriting in the insurance sense
Where it falls short
- Not insurance — payment of your bills is not legally guaranteed
- Not regulated by state insurance departments; no guaranty fund
- Pre-existing conditions are commonly excluded or phased in slowly
- Membership often requires meeting lifestyle or religious criteria
- You negotiate and submit bills yourself far more than with insurance
Private PPO
What it does well
- A regulated insurance contract — the carrier owes you the benefit
- State insurance department oversight and a complaints process
- Defined networks and negotiated in-network rates
- Pre-existing conditions can be covered depending on underwriting
Where it falls short
- Usually a higher monthly cost than a sharing contribution
- Medically underwritten
If the difference between 'we intend to share this cost' and 'the carrier is contractually obliged to pay' matters to you — and for most people facing a five-figure bill it matters enormously — a regulated private PPO is the sounder choice.
When the other option wins
You're healthy, the community model genuinely fits your values, and you understand and accept that payment isn't guaranteed.
Health Sharing Ministry and a private PPO, row by row.
- Is it insurance?Health Sharing Ministry:No, members share costsPrivate PPO:Yes, a regulated insurance contract
- Payment of claimsHealth Sharing Ministry:Not guaranteedPrivate PPO:Contractually owed
- Pre-existing conditionsHealth Sharing Ministry:Waiting periods or limits commonPrivate PPO:Can be covered, subject to underwriting
- RegulatorHealth Sharing Ministry:Generally not state insurance departmentsPrivate PPO:Your state department of insurance
- Membership rulesHealth Sharing Ministry:Often lifestyle or faith requirementsPrivate PPO:No lifestyle requirements
- Monthly costHealth Sharing Ministry:Usually lowPrivate PPO:Low, with a contract behind it
The honest answers.
Why is health sharing so cheap?
Because it isn't insurance. Members agree to share eligible bills, but nothing obliges the organization to pay a given claim, and it isn't held to the rules an insurer is.
Who do I complain to if a bill isn't shared?
Usually the organization itself. State insurance departments generally don't regulate health sharing ministries, so there is far less outside recourse than with an insurance plan.
Can health sharing still be the right choice?
For some people, yes, especially if the community and values matter to them and they understand the lack of a guarantee going in.
Health Sharing Ministry is best if
- The community and shared values matter to you
- You accept that payment isn't guaranteed
- You meet the membership rules
A private PPO is best if
- You want claims owed under contract
- You want a state regulator in your corner
- You have a condition that sharing rules would limit
Everything above is general information, not advice about your situation and not a quote. Plan availability, pricing and underwriting vary by state and carrier.
Three steps, and you're never locked in.
- 01
Tell us the basics
State, household, pre-existing conditions and timing. About thirty seconds — no SSN, no date of birth.
- 02
A licensed advisor reaches out
Real options, real costs and the honest trade-offs, in plain English.
- 03
You decide
Enroll if it fits, or don't. No cost to talk and no obligation at any point.
See what you actually qualify for.
Four questions, a licensed advisor, a straight answer. No cost, no obligation, no pressure.
Secure & private. By submitting you agree to be contacted by a licensed advisor.
Year-round enrollment
Private PPO plans are not tied to open enrollment.
Never sold
Your details are not passed to a lead list.
256-bit SSL encrypted
Your details are protected from the first click.
No cost, no obligation
Talking it through is free. You decide.
Step 1 of 5
Let's find your coverage